Skip to main content

Ending Time Out (Part 2)

picture of relaxing is used to represent the environment of appropriate timeout

Let's continue the conversation about time out.  In the last post I said there were two issues with time out that I wanted to explore with you:

1.) Time out is not a catchall consequence for all behaviors, it has a specific purpose.
2.) Time out should be called time away, and this is not a minor distinction.

We covered "Time out is not a Catchall" in Part 1, and if you have not read it yet, I encourage you to read that one first.  I essentially explained that time out should be used strategically as a method of teaching, not a punitive consequence.  In this post we will explore the branding behind the term "Time Away" as opposed to "Time Out".

Time Out should be called Time Away

Remember that discipline should be all about helping our children to learn appropriate behaviors, while still meeting their needs.  It is easy to take this philosophy and think that time out really should be used often.  It appears to teach them that when they are unable to maintain their behavior they should step out of the limelight and have a quick reset, but because of the way we use it, it often fails to do this.

We need to consider the need behind the behaviors.  All behaviors stem from a need, and needs come in a certain order.  Maslow identified that we must establish our most basic needs like food and water before we can really even process higher needs like self esteem.  A sense of belonging is so basic that it comes right after our need for safety.  When we use time out we are communicating that our children don't belong with other people, they don't even belong with us.  This means that any use of isolation should only be used when the issue we are addressing is so important that we are willing to challenge their sense of belonging in the family.  Ideally these are only issues that fit in the two categories below "belonging", leaving the intervention as a useful tactic for addressing health and safety issues only.

A change in language can help us to use a similar technique without limiting us quite so much.  Time out is established in our minds, and the minds of our children, as a punitive time of forced isolation in response to unacceptable behavior.  Time away, is a new term and allows us to establish new ground rules without fighting tradition and bias.

Time away is a time for our children to step away from a situation without being "out" of the family.  Away, is intuitively temporary as well.  I know that may sound like simple word play, but it can be a powerful re-framing tool for the child and a powerful reminder of the consequence's purpose to adults.  Time away is not isolation, approved useful items and even people may join them for their time away.  Time away ends when they check back in rather then at a set arbitrary time.  This helps them to know that they can still approach their parents, even when they are in trouble.  The parents can help them to process if they are really ready to resume regular activities.  This processing can help them to learn their own rhythms and needs, eventually leading to the ability to self regulate.

I could go into much more detail, but I want to keep these posts short and approachable.

Please leave your comments below, if you have questions I can address I will do my best to help you out with an answer.  The Art of Family is all about helping you practice the art of "family" like the verb that it is.  You can help us out by sharing this site with other parents that you know.  Thank you for your precious time!


Popular posts from this blog

Divine | Shame | Humans

Shame is often the only thing between our creator and us. Our reading this week is from Job 14:5-6: A person’s days are determined;      you have decreed the number of his months      and have set limits he cannot exceed. So look away from him and let him alone,      till he has put in his time like a hired laborer. Job is struggling with shame and judgement.  He is wondering why God is spending time paying attention to him, a tiny speck in the great universe, a blink of an eye in all eternity.  Why would God waste time casting a glance at us, let alone fostering us, raising us, and disciplining us?  He cries out "Why won't God just let us be, to live out our miserable existence?" A friend shared a post with me on Facebook this week.  It was a video of her dog who had stolen her donut.  The dog had been under the bed for two hours before she started the video.  The video begins with a clear view of the dog and the uneaten donut under the bed.  The dog casts glances from s

Justice & Privilege

The narrative lectionary reading for this week begins a 5 week series on the book of Job.  We focus on Job 1:1-12.  This first section sets the background for the parable.  It is important to note that this is clearly a parable, not a historical text.  This means we must look beyond the described events and towards a deeper meaning within the text.   The story goes like this: ___ There was once a man who thought he was good, an upright citizen, a religiously devout man.  He made good choices and avoided all forms of evil.  He was so pious that he made sacrifices in the name of his family members in case they had unknowingly sinned.  He had great wealth and privilege, and so this was evidence of his goodness.   God was so pleased with this great man, named Job, that he bragged about him to the accuser.  The accuser objected "Of course Job is good, you have provided him with wealth, power, and protection. He would curse you if he was not so privileged."  At this, God takes the

Fool for Christ

Our reading from the Narrative Lectionary this week is 2 Corinthians 5.  Verse 13 stood out to me. If it seems we are crazy, it is to bring glory to God. - 2 Corinthians 5:13a (NLT) John Wimber, the founder of the Vineyard churches did a famous sermon called "I am a fool for Christ, whose fool are you?".  Reading this week's text reminded me of this wonderful sermon.  Wimber's sermon reminds us that, as christians, we are called to something truly radical.  The christian walk is strange and counter cultural.  Jesus once explained this to his disciples in John 15 "If you belonged to the world, it would love you as its own. You don't belong to this world, I have chosen you out of it.  That is why the world hates you."   Peter, in a letter to the church, later referred to all of us as strangers just passing through this world.   Do you feel like a stranger?  Do you feel like the world hates you?  Are you a fool for Christ? Here is the thing, you are going t