Skip to main content

Logic & Experience


Our reading from the Narrative Lectionary this week is from Acts 17:1-9.  Paul comes into a new town and begins teaching about Jesus in the synagogue.  He teaches for three weeks in a row and converts many, but upsets the religious leaders.  When they see his success they create a mob and try to arrest Paul.  When they can't find him they arrest the owner of the home he was staying in. 

What struck me this week is the dedication and love Paul had for the Jewish communities he had grown up in.  At this point he already had much more success and had more in common with the gentile believers, but he was consistent about going to the Jews first, and he only stopped trying to convert them after being forced to by law, or physical force. In a time when it is a cultural norm to hop from church to church over minor theological differences, musical tastes, or social circles, this is a message we desperately need.

Paul did not give up on his faith community, he worked to be the change he wanted to see.  He was criticized and abused for it, but the church as a whole is better today because of his efforts.  He didn't simply start a new church, he used the scriptures to make logical arguments, and he used his own experience to share anecdotal evidence.  The Jewish leaders were stuck in their ways and refuted both, and we should learn from their mistake, but we often recreate the same church culture that beat Paul nearly to death several times. 

Since many of us choose a church that fits our beliefs and tastes best, we are surrounded by people who think and believe like us.  This creates long standing tradition and thought echo chambers.  When a new idea is presented with logic, we argue "God's ways are not like our ways", or "Man's wisdom is foolishness to God".  When confronted with examples of personal experiences that question our traditions or deeply held beliefs, we ignore them as the "logical fallacy of anecdotal evidence".  We note that it is our responsibility to protect the flock from false teachers and wolves in sheep clothing.  I imagine the Jews from Thessalonica thought they were offering a similar service to their community. 

It is this type of thinking that has kept churches progressing slowly on issues like women & LGBTQ leaders, as well as any form of modern scientific symbiosis. Hearts have been hardened and lines have been drawn in the sand.  Churches have divided and created their own echo chambers on both ends of the arguments.  We have lost the diversity within the individual bodies that once allowed us to sharpen one another. 

Churches need to begin drawing their circle of who is welcome much larger, to adopt a generous orthodoxy, our faith has a long tradition of it.  We don't need to agree to belong.  Individuals on the fringes need to stay in place and help be the change they want to see instead of creating new echo chambers.  Those in the accepted orthodoxy need to let their defenses down a little and listen to the stirring voices in their community, they are prompting you towards progress, and they are part of the body too.       

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Death Will Lose it's Sting

Our reading from the Narrative Lectionary this week is 1 Corinthians 15:51-57. In these verses, Paul reveals a mystery, that in the end some will be transformed, given a new body, instead of facing death.  In other words death is not one of life's two certain terms.  It seems taxes may be the only guarantee.   "...in this world nothing can be said to be certain, except  death and taxes ." - Benjamin Franklin. Ok, all jokes aside, these verses are difficult to read.  Paul looks forward to a time when death will have no victory, it will have lost its sting.  But today, we are in the middle of a pandemic, surrounded by death.  Many are scared for their lives, or their loved ones, and too many have already been lost.  Death does not seem to have lost its sting at all, it feels as if it is closing in. When I worked in wilderness therapy I remember holding a child who was desperately trying to kill himself.  We cried together as he struggled to end it, and I struggled

The Return Threshold

  As we come near the end of our weekly series on the Hero's Journey, today we will cover "The Return Threshold".  In this stage, the Hero has succeeded in their quest and now they are coming back to their old world.  Joseph Campbell calls this the "ordinary world".   The return to the ordinary world usually includes some type of challenge.  Sometimes an enemy must be challenged, but sometimes the enemy is the ordinary world itself.  As we have followed the hero's journey we have seen the hero change, what was once important is no longer important.  While the hero has changed, the ordinary world has not.  The ordinary world holds values that the returning hero has abandoned for something greater.  This can cause tension as the hero tries to return as a changed person. In the Lord of the Rings trilogy, we see the Hobbits finally return to their home in the Shire.  Unfortunately in their absence Saruman and his orcs have taken over the Shire and must be defeat

Master of Two Worlds

  This week we come to the second to last stage of the Hero's Journey.  Campbell called this stage "The Master of Two Worlds".  In this stage, the hero tries to integrate what they learned and gained on their journey with their old "ordinary" world.   Albert Einstein once said, "If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough."  This explains the challenge the hero must face in this stage.  All that they learned and gained must be fully mastered and the test of this mastery is being able to use it in the ordinary world.  They must simplify it so that the uninitiated can benefit from it, just as Einstein encouraged the mastery of complex ideas into simple explanations.   In the Star Wars Trilogy, this stage happens off-screen after the film is over, but before the new movie begins.  We learn in the newest trilogy that Luke created a school for Jedi, taking the wisdom he gained from his journey and sharing it with others.  In